Shake Sugary brings to you handmade, homemade, all natural fare that can turn any day into a sweeter one!

Our cakes and pastries are baked from scratch in small batches using local and organic ingredients when possible. Why not bring one of our specialty cakes, cookies or other treats to a friend as a tasty birthday gift. Place a pastry order for an office party, school function, business meeting, or family get-together. We can customize assorted platters and dessert trays to fit your fancy! Bite size treats also available by special order.  All items are baked fresh to order!

please allow 24 hrs. notice for all orders or 48 hrs. for special orders and decorated cakes

PLEASE NOTE: ALL BREAKFAST ITEMS REQUIRE A MINIMUM HALF DOZEN ORDER PER FLAVOR.

Jumbo Muffins
$18 1/2 dz. – $32 dozen

mixed berry, lemon poppyseed, banana nut, apple cinnamon, pumpkin apple, pumpkin chocolate chip, blueberry, strawberry lemon, raspberry, cranberry orange, sausage roasted red pepper corn muffin . . . . or make a request for your favorite flavor!


Scones
$18 1/2 dz. – $32 dozen

orange chocolate chip, lemon poppyseed, banana nut, raspberry white chocolate chip, strawberry banana, peaches and cream, berry lemon, apple oatmeal, pumpkin streusel, maple walnut, cranberry orange, apricot white chocolate chip

Sweet Rolls
$18 1/2 dz. $32 dozen

Apple Cinnamon, Pecan Sticky, or Orange Marmalade
A buttery yeast dough filled with brown sugar, and spiced filling with cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, and cardamon topped with sweet vanilla glaze.

Maple Bacon Sweet Potato Biscuits
$32 dozen

A big flaky sweet potato biscuit combining sweet maple syrup with salty bacon makes a scrumptious breakfast treat.

Danish Pastries
$18 1/2 dz. $32 dozen

Apricot Puff Pastry or Spinach Feta Turnover

$14/loaf

Tea-Breads are sweet quick breads traditionally enjoyed with your favorite coffee or tea that come in a variety of delicious flavors. Our tea-breads are perfect for breakfast, a light snack, or for dessert!

Orange-Almond Poppyseed
Banana Chocolate Chip
Morning Glory
Orange Blossom & Jasmine Green Tea
Lemon Ginger Cream-Cheese

$9 1/2 dozen – $18 dozen

Thick, chewy and delicious oversized gourmet cookies made using the freshest all natural ingredients.

Old-Fashioned Chocolate Chip
White Chocolate Cherry Fudge
Cran-Orange White Chocolate Oatmeal
Citrus White Chocolate Coconut Macaroons
Fudge Peanut Butter Chip
Mocha Chocolate Pecan
Chewy Ginger Molasses

Herb Infused Shortbread Cookies

$10 dozen

Crisp, buttery shortbread cookies baked with unique herb and spice flavor combinations. They’re delicious on their own or with a cup of hot tea. Currently offering the following flavors: Lemon Basil, Rosemary Walnut, Mexican Chocolate, Curry, and Chocolate Tarragon

Cranberry – Nut Granola

$5.00 8oz. bag – $10.00 16oz. bag

Homemade granola packed with crunchy oats, slivered almonds, pecans, coconut, cinnamon and a medley of dried fruit that is sure to keep you going throughout your day.

$15 1/2 dozen – $30 dozen

Chocolate Dipped Salted Caramel Pecan Bars
Old-Fashioned Fudge Brownies
White Chocolate Kahlua Cream-Cheese Brownies
Apple Walnut Crunch Bars
White Chocolate Chai Spiced Blondies
Pecan Praline Blondies
Lemon Shortbread Bars
Cranberry Amaretto Coconut Bars
Blueberry Buckle Bars*

*seasonal

4″ Individual $3.50 – 10″ Deep Dish Pies $26

Keylime Pie with Graham Cracker Crust
Almond Raspberry Buttermilk Pie
Sweet Potato Praline Pie
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie
Caramel Apple Streusel Pie

4″ Individual $3.50 – 8″ 10″ Tarts $26

Seasonal Fresh Fruit Tart
Citrus Berry Tart
Dark Chocolate Orange Truffle Tart

8″ $30 – 10″ $40

Amaretto Praline
Bailey’s Chocolate Chip
Turtle
Apple Brandy
Chocolate Kahlua
Raspberry White Chocolate Swirl

$30 dozen

PLEASE NOTE: EACH FLAVOR REQUIRES A MINIMUM ORDER OF ONE DOZEN

Banana Chocolate Chip:

banana chocolate chip cupcake with mocha hazelnut filling and cinnamon buttercream frosting

Sweet Potato Praline:

sweet potato cupcake with cream-cheese frosting topped with homemade pecan praline bits

Lemon Honey:

honey sweetened lemon cupcake with lemon-honey frosting

Orange Creamsicle:

orange cupcake with dreamy orange cream-cheese frosting

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup:

dark chocolate cupcake with fluffy peanut butter frosting glazed with rich chocolate ganache

Lemon Ginger:

lemon ginger cream cheese poundcake with ginger cream cheese frosting

Triple Apple Spice:

spice cake with apples done 3 ways and sweet maple buttercream

Delicious bundt cakes

$22

Lemon Ginger Cream-Cheese
Coconut Lime
Double Chocolate
Amaretto Cinnamon Swirl
Irish Cream & Coffee
Berry Buttermilk* (using fresh berries of the season)

Luscious layer cakes

8″ $28 – 10″ $34 – 1/4 sheet (9×13) $42 – 1/2 sheet (12×18) $50

Banana Chocolate Chip Cake:

3 layers of moist banana chocolate chip cake with a light chocolate hazelnut filling iced with cinnamon buttercream

Chocolate Raspberry Ganache:

3 layers of rich chocolaty cake filled with sweet raspberry buttercream & glazed with dark chocolate ganache

German Chocolate Cake:

3 layers of moist chocolate cake filled with gooey caramel, coconut & pecans, iced with chocolate buttercream

Craisin Ginger Carrot Cake:

3 layers of fluffy carrot cake with a hint of citrus filled & iced with ginger cream cheese frosting

Hummingbird Cake:

3 layers of perfectly spiced banana, pineapple & pecan cake, filled & iced with ginger cream cheese frosting (also great with caramel buttercream!)

Italian Cream Cake:

3 layers of coconut, pecan white cake, filled and iced with coconut white chocolate cream cheese frosting (can be iced with buttercream upon request)

Tripple Apple Delight:

3 layers of triple apple spice cake (applesauce, apple butter, fresh apples) filled & iced with maple rum buttercream

Fluffy Coconut Layer Cake:

3 layers of fluffy coconut cake, filled & iced with buttercream & covered in sweet coconut

Mocha Amaretto Torte:

4 layers of almond sponge cake brushed with a coffee syrup, filled with amaretto pastry cream, iced with mocha buttercream & garnished with toasted almonds

Strawberry Passion-fruit Champagne Layer Cake:

4 layers of bubbly pink champagne cake brushed with champagne syrup, filled with passionfruit custard & fresh strawberries & iced with strawberry buttercream

Chocolate Mousse Torte:

4 layers of rich chocolate cake layered with creamy chocolate mousse & glazed with dark chocolate ganache

Green Tea Opera Cake:

4 layers of almond sponge cake brushed with coffee syrup and sandwiched with alternating layers of green tea buttercream, mocha buttercream and dark chocolate ganache
*only available in 6×9, 1/4 sht. (9×13) & 1/2 sht. (12×18) sizes

Chocolate Hazelnut Decadence Torte:

rich, dense chocolate hazelnut flourless torte glazed with dark chocolate ganache . . . pure decadence!